X

Your Cart is Empty

0
Midwest Stollen
Midwest Stollen
Seasonal
Midwest Stollen
Regular price
$49.95
Sale price
$49.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A Large Blueberry Coffee Cake
A Large Blueberry Coffee Cake
Best Seller
Blueberry Coffee Cake
Regular price
from $45.00
Sale price
from $45.00
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Honeycrisp Apple Conserve
A jar of Honeycrisp Apple Conserve
Limited Release
Honeycrisp Apple Conserve
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Black Mission Fig Conserve
Regular price
$16.95
Sale price
$16.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Quince Conserve
A jar of Quince Conserve
Limited Release
Quince Conserve
Regular price
$18.95
Sale price
$18.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
ā€œThe standout winner. Tasters liked its bold, ripe peach taste and balanced sweetness.ā€

ā€” Cook's Illustrated

A platter of mixed grilled sausages with ramekins of mustard for dipping.
A platter of mixed grilled sausages with ramekins of mustard for dipping.
New
Golden Ale Mustard
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Spiced Pear Conserve
A jar of Spiced Pear Conserve
Limited Release
Spiced Pear Conserve
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Cherry Berry Conserve
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Wildflower Honey Mustard
A jar of Wildflower Honey Mustard
Best Seller
Wildflower Honey Mustard
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Whole Seed Mustard
A jar of Whole Seed Mustard
Best Seller
Whole Seed Mustard
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
ā€œAmerican Spoon's Sour Cherry Preserves are so packed with fruit, it's basically like spreading soft, cooked whole cherries onto your breadā€

ā€” Serious Eats

House Ketchup
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Jar of tomato pasta sauce
Jar of tomato pasta sauce
New
Pasta Sauce
Regular price
$21.95
Sale price
$21.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
JalapeƱo Pepper Jelly
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Peach Habanero Jelly
A jar of Peach Habanero Jelly
Limited Release
Peach Habanero Jelly
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Chili Jam
A jar of Chili Jam
Best Seller
Chili Jam
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Roasted Tomatillo Salsa
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Pumpkin Seed Salsa
A jar of Pumpkin Seed Salsa
Best Seller
Pumpkin Seed Salsa
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Dried Chile Salsa
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Pumpkin Chipotle Roasting Sauce
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Cherry Peach Salsa
A jar of Cherry Peach Salsa
Best Seller
Cherry Peach Salsa
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Mango Habanero Salsa
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Smoky Corn Salsa
A jar of Smoky Corn Salsa
Best Seller
Smoky Corn Salsa
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Tomato & Cilantro Salsa
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Apple & Onion Jam
A jar of Apple & Onion Jam
Best Seller
Apple and Onion Jam
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Cucumber Pickle Relish
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Farmhouse Tomato Relish
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Smoky Backyard BBQ Sauce
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Apple Cider Grilling Sauce
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Cherry BBQ Grilling Sauce
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Maple BBQ Grilling Sauce
Regular price
$13.95
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Pumpkin Butter
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Apple Butter
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Red Raspberry Butter
Regular price
$15.95
Sale price
$15.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Sour Cherry Spoon Fruit
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Blueberry Spoon Fruit
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Red Raspberry Spoon Fruit
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
New
Candied Pecans, 8 oz.
Regular price
$24.95
Sale price
$24.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Canister of Candied Pecans
Canister of Candied Pecans
New
Candied Pecans, 16 oz.
Regular price
$39.95
Sale price
$39.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Askinosie Chocolate Bar
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Dried Tart Cherries, 12 oz
Regular price
$15.95
Sale price
$15.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Apricot Jam
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Wild Thimbleberry Jam
A jar of Wild Thimbleberry Jam
Limited Release
Wild Thimbleberry Jam
Regular price
$35.95
Sale price
$35.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
A jar of Wild Elderberry Jam
A jar of Wild Elderberry Jam
Limited Release
Wild Elderberry Jelly
Regular price
$18.95
Sale price
$18.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Honey Dipper
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
Jam Spoon
Regular price
$15.95
Sale price
$15.95
Regular price
Unit price
per 
New
Sour Cherry Preserves Four-Pack
Regular price
$50.00
Sale price
$50.00
Regular price
Unit price
per 
back-to-top
Sale
- +

Unavailable

Sold Out